End of Season Review

The Spoiler’s top ten Premiership games of 2008/09

The games that have made this season worth watching

Now that Manchester Utd have pretty much put the final nail in the coffin of the 2008/09 Premier League title race, it’s high time that we start peddling out some end of season lists. Accordingly, here is a top ten of the campaign’s most entertaining matches, which somehow includes a game involving West Brom…

#10: West Brom 3 – 2 West Ham, 13th September

West Brom 3 - 2 West Ham

Gianfranco Zola must have been wondering what he’d signed himself up for, watching his first West Ham game from the stands before taking over as manager. A game with a neutral-baiting mix of awful defending and open attacking play, both teams managed to lose their lead twice before an 83rd minute West Brom counter attack saw Chris Brunt sprint free of the Hammers’ defence and clinically place one inside the far post.

#9: Fulham 0 – 0 Sunderland, 18th October

Fulham 0 - 0 Sunderland

Sunderland’s early visit to Craven Cottage should go down as the best goalless game of the season. Fulham’s goalmouth literally took a battering. Kieron Richardson, taking time off from his usual job of lying on a physio’s table somewhere, had his 25-yard free-kick bounce between the posts twice (before having another free-kick goal disallowed) and Djibril Cisse’s rasping long ranger was saved by the crossbar. However, the Cottagers created their own opportunities in the back-and-forth battle, with Zoltan Gera having a shot cleared off the line from Pascal Chimbonda before spurning his team’s best chance with a Carragher-esque air kick.

#8: Fulham 2 – 0 Manchester Utd, 21st March

Fulham 2 - 0 Manchester Utd

It’s testament to how crap United were in the first half of this game that by the time Paul Scholes’ baffling handball earned Fulham a penalty in the 18th minute, the home team had already done more than enough to deserve a lead. United tried to rally in the second half, but the pressure of facing back-to-back losses and Liverpool still breathing down their necks showed. Wayne Rooney’s attempt to ‘return the ball’ to a free-kick spot by launching it over-arm toward the ref’s legs at 300mph earned him a red card a minute from time. A historic win for Fulham, and another strong argument in Roy Hodgson’s claim for Manager of the Year – at the same point last year, Fulham were four points adrift from safety.

#7: Manchester City 2 – 3 Liverpool, 5th October

Manchester City 2 - 3 Liverpool

At the risk of flogging a well-worn footballing cliché into atoms, this genuinely was a game of two halves. After a fairly rubbish start to the season – three wins and three losses – City looked like they were about prove they could crash the top 4 love-in. Within 45 minutes of champagne football worthy of their champagne price tags, they’d put two past Liverpool, with Javier Garrido swinging one of the best free-kicks of the season inside Pep Reina’s near post for City’s second. But Liverpool turned the tables in the second half, slicing through the Blues’ defence at will, with irrepressible carthorse Dirk Kuyt smashing home the winner in the 92nd minute. Managing to retain their unbeaten record in all competitions, it was one of the first indicators Liverpool might have enough resilience to sustain a worthwhile title bid.

Interesting fact: Xabi Alonso’s extremely hackable legs claimed their thirrd victim of the season in this game (six in total), with Pablo Zabaleta’s sending off in the 67th minute.

#6: Manchester Utd 1 – 4 Liverpool, 14th March

Manchester Utd 1 - 4 Liverpool

Although United were still four points in front once the final whistle had blown, it was a defeat that could’ve severely tripped up their title sprint. Liverpool could gain confidence from a myriad of factors: Rafa had secured his first win at Old Trafford, they’d stopped United breaking their own record of 11 successive league victories, Vidic was made to look like something out of a U9s reserve team and Wayne Rooney was made to look like a bit of a knob, days after previously expressing his hate for the Scousers. All of this wrapped up in an impressive, emphatic comeback package.

#5: Arsenal 2 – 1 Manchester Utd, 8th November

Arsenal 2 - 1 Manchester Utd

A result that must now keep Wenger up at night. Where did it all go wrong, Professor? In the first meeting of the season between the two title rivals, an under-strength Arsenal managed to keep an excellent game of football at a frenetic pace (the stats worked out as a shot on goal nearly every 3 minutes). Even with Nicklas Bendtner leading the line, Arsenal survived a pummelling during the second half, showing a strength of mind that was all too lacking by the end of the season.

#4: Everton 2 – 3 Aston Villa, 7th December

Everton 2 - 3 Aston Villa

This was the scene of one of the most hilarious moments of the season: Young Frankenstein-a-like Joleon Lescott stropping off the pitch the second the whistle was blown, just a minute after raucously celebrating what looked like a priceless point in the battle to break the top four. Around 30 seconds earlier, Ashley Young had stolen in from an Agbonglahor pass, turned Lescott like a door handle and slotted one past Tim Howard. Ironically, it was the sort of late defensive crumbling that eventually became Villa’s calling card as the second half of the season progressed.

#3: Manchester City 6 – 0 Portsmouth, 21st September

Manchester City 6 - 0 Portsmouth

Once the transfer window shut last summer, it was hard not to be curious as to what impact the league’s newly minted club would have on the season. In the end, the answer was ‘little to none’, discounting a festive period spent knocking around the relegation zone. But at the start of the season, the 6-0 win at Eastlands looked like a Harlem Globetrotters exhibition game, offering a hint of the entertainment City’s Saudi-Brazilian revolution could serve up. Choosing to rely on his perpetually useless 3-5-2 formation, Harry Redknapp saw his team taken apart by Robinho, Wright-Phillips, Ireland and the rest of the rampant Blues’ attack, with six different players helping themselves to a goal.

#2: Arsenal 4 – 4 Tottenham, 30th October

Arsenal 4 - 4 Tottenham

One of the most exciting London derbies in recent memory, with ‘Arry managing to galvanise his reputation as a managerial magician by leading a revitalised Spurs team to a point at the Emirates. A typical derby, it was defined by fluffed chances and suicidal defending, Aaron Lennon sealing the equaliser seconds before the final whistle. The match was also the scene of David Bentley’s sole contribution to the 2008/09 season, a genius 40-yard lob which remains a contender for goal of the season. The result had a telling impact on the two teams: Spurs going on to win 2-1 against Liverpool, while Arsenal succumbed to Rory Delap FC in their next game.

#1: Liverpool 4 – 4 Arsenal, 21st April

Liverpool 4 - 4 Arsenal

Our game of the season and one that should go down as an all-time classic: Liverpool 4, Arshavin 4. Essentially with nothing to play for in the league, most fans expected Arsenal to accept being dispatched by a goal or two as they let Liverpool get on with the business of chasing their title dream. Andrei Arshavin though, had different ideas. Scoring from every one of his – and Arsenal’s – shots on target, he was the catalyst for the lead changing hands four times in the course of 90 minutes. Crap keeping, anonymous defenders – it was playground football at its finest.

Words and research: Richard Gilzene

18 responses so far
  • Lewis // May 15, 2009 at 2:40 pm

    Guessing whoever wrote this was a liverpool fan then. Shame you won’t win the league! How about when United beat Chelsea 3-0? Not good enough to make it but a 0-0 draw was. Idiot

  • middo // May 15, 2009 at 2:56 pm

    What about Arsenal V Hull.

    City even scored thiers!

  • shay // May 15, 2009 at 2:59 pm

    Interesting that you only included games that Manchester United lost and yet they must have won a few because they are at the top of the table. No bias at all right. What’s wrong, did Cristiano f**k your girlfriend or something. You really are an idiot.

  • Paul D // May 15, 2009 at 3:14 pm

    Ah lovely to see the Mancs are in their usual fine mood today.

    Even as a Pool fan, ManU-Villa match was a Top 3 contender here in pure football terms, even though it broke my heart.

  • gamblos // May 15, 2009 at 3:27 pm

    Right about the writer being a Liverpool fan bit.

    Calling Joleon “Frankenstein-a-like” did it for me. Nice one you prick.

    Good choice of matches though.

  • Reece // May 15, 2009 at 3:46 pm

    Man U – Chelsea 3-0 wasn’t a big deal because Chelsea were on a terrible run of form for a top 4 and Man U were unbeatable. Not even playing at their best and they won.

    Getting 2-0ed by Fulham was bound to get in though since it was just about the upset of the season and basically set up the Liverpool comeback prospect.

    I have to disagree with the 0-0 though. It was probably exciting for the fans but it was hardly a high-skills match.

  • tijuanakid // May 15, 2009 at 5:17 pm

    Haha…every time United lose, it is a match of the season!

    Fulham-Sunderland over Man U-Villa and Man U-Spurs….hilarious.

  • David // May 15, 2009 at 5:50 pm

    love how you guys all bitch at the top 10 picks because the writer’s a liverpool fan. if anything, you should look at picking the united losses as the writer admitting his team is inferior to united because when they do in fact lose, it’s a big deal.

    and i will say that the two fulham games are well deserved on this list. both were great for different reasons, and they are the surprise of the season without a doubt.

  • Raph88 // May 15, 2009 at 8:01 pm

    well, considering that man u win 99% of their matches against the bottom 14 then surely any loss can be called one of the matches of season simply due to the rarity element. plus they usually lose in special circumstances, i.e. rooney boxing the flag.

  • Shaun // May 15, 2009 at 8:58 pm

    Man Utd Vs Spurs 2-0 down at half time 5-2 full time, not in top 10! But you put a 0-0 draw in there, god your an idiot!

  • barner // May 16, 2009 at 12:26 am

    the #1 game shouldnt be at the top the man u 1-4 lfc should be first place as it was much more entertaining than the 4-4 one so many mistakes in that one

  • Mizman // May 16, 2009 at 2:26 am


    are you watching merseyside?

  • jimmy // May 16, 2009 at 3:04 am

    man utd-villa should be there instead of man city portsmouth 6-0.
    that one was boring after 2-0.the same way liverpool newcastle 5-1 was boring in the second half.

  • haycomel // May 17, 2009 at 1:27 am

    Emm..how about when Mboro beat Lfc 2-0!! It’s much more exciting since Mboro was at bottom of the table at that time(even now~~struggling at the relegation zone)…

  • Luke // May 17, 2009 at 1:35 am

    The 5 – 2 against the Spurs wasn’t entertaining, a team crumbled to pieces of what they were in the first half. And like that, most ManU wins are the same, not really exciting since the other team can’t do much against their squad.
    Otherwise, when they lose, it means the other team played exceptionally well.

  • jimmy // May 17, 2009 at 2:06 am

    exactly, luke. man utd are pro efficient. other teams just give up against them. thats why when they lose, it becomes exciting.

    boro beating liverpool – all i can remember is that boro beat liverpool. nothing top ten about that.

    i dont like the 6-0. man utd – villa. would have been the obvious better choice. although, i dont get the 0-0. maybe i didn’t watch it. otherwise a good enough list.

  • reD // May 17, 2009 at 10:45 am

    While I acknowledge that United have a better group of players, I think this list proves that the better side hasn’t won the title this year. Liverpool have been by far the best team to watch this year, and I’m gutted that hasn’t resulted in the title. Oh well, there’s always next year…

    Come on Barca!

  • Stevie the K // May 17, 2009 at 12:39 pm

    Agree on #1, but your #4 should have been second.

Leave a comment
  1. View comments in RSS feed